I recently received a copy of Pearl Buck in China to read and review. I'll admit that I had never heard of Pearl Buck when I agreed to read the book, so I wasn't sure just how interested I would be in this biography written by Hilary Spurling.
Â
First, some brief info on Pearl Buck. She born in 1892 as the daughter of missionaries living in China. She grew up to become a Pulitzer Prize winning author (for 1931's "The Good Earth") and later won the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1938. She lived in China exclusively from the age of 3 months until she left for college in America. Upon graduation from Randolph-Macon College in Virginia she returned to China, where she lived for for twenty years until the Communist political climate (and a total mistrust of Americans) caused she and her husband to move back to America permanently. As I said, I had never heard of Pearl Buck, but found myself enjoying her story – both as an author and as a Presbyterian missionary in her own right – and have been inspired to add "The Good Earth" to my reading wish list.Â
Â
What I did not enjoy, however, was the audiobook. Perhaps if I had been reading physical pages I would have forgiven a lot, but I didn't have that luxury. The audiobook was read by the author (ALWAYS a mistake, I've found) in such a way that it almost made the riveting account of Pearl's life completely uninteresting. It was a struggle at times to listen to the author read her book – whether she was mispronouncing words (it's "frugality," not "frugrality") or ending sentences in such a way that it sounded like she didn't actually finish them.Â
Â
I also got a sense that I wasn't reading a biography so much as a dissertation about Pearl Buck. Having gone through the process of writing a senior thesis myself while in college, I absolutely got the sense that the author was spending the whole book attempting to prove something. And yet, as I got to the final five minutes of the book – I got no conclusion. The book just ends. Without really ending at all. Very dissatisfying.
Â
Having said that, do I recommend this book? Sure – but not the audiobook. If you can handle dry, just-the-facts writing then you'll be able to get through this one and will probably feel inspired to buy "The Good Earth." Then again – I might just recommend you get "The Good Earth" and get your inspiration from there instead.
Â
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this audiobook free from Oasis Audio as part of their Review Program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising."
I have listened to a few, not many, books narrated by the author that were really good. Tops in the category, IMO: When Character Was King, by Peggy Noonan.